Update: Morningstar finally puts on shorts

You may recall that we had a bone to pick with Morningstar about the absence of any short data on their website (“Existing mutual fund analysis woefully unprepared for 130/30“).

Well “John C” updates the story today with the following comment added to the posting:

Interesting read! For the first time today, I noticed that Morningstar has started to include shorts on their portfolio analysis pages. For example, take a look at this:


When you click on the top holdings, you now see both long and short positions:


Still, there are improvements to be made, but this is a step in the right direction.

He’s right. The ING 130/30 fund, for example, now includes this nifty graph (circled):

So after walking around with no shorts for some time now, we’re glad to see the venerable outfit cover up a little.

Be Sociable, Share!

One Comment

  1. Jay Compson
    October 2, 2007 at 4:33 pm

    Morningstar may have shorts, but they don’t know how to analyze them. This week’s Investment News article “Pride of the Quants” quotes a Morningstar analyst saying, “130/30 funds were able to maneuver through August volatility unscathed.” Why? Because they were flat for the month? Given that these products have an average beta of 1.0 to the S&P 500, that means the “30/30 part” was DOWN 5% for the month! Hardly “maneuvering unscathed” and much worse than market neutral funds.

Leave A Reply

← Assessing Hedge Fund Performance: Does the Choice of Measures Matter? On the Relative Performance of Multi-Strategy and Funds of Hedge Funds →